Tuesday, May 01, 2007

What do we remember?

Well, it's May 1st. There are a whole bunch of things traditionally celebrated on May Day, but I usually think of International Workers' Day. Most industrialized countries celebrate their Labor Day today, in memory of the workers who were brutally suppressed at Haymarket Square right here in Chicago back in the 1880's. The raw emotions so many people attached to that event in the United States led President Cleveland to put US Labor Day in September. But people still remember. For example, immigrant laborers remember. They took to the streets of Chicago in a peaceful demonstration one year ago today:

Cleveland failed to make people forget about Haymarket just by moving the holiday. Ironically, George W. Bush, the most anti-labor President since the Great Depression, has distracted people from that tragic day without doing anything labor-related. You see, Democrats remember May 1st, 2003 as the day Bush declared "Mission Accomplished" aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln. Democrats sent the supplemental funding bill to Bush today as a means of commemorating that great speech.

The Bush camp has denied having anything to do with the infamous banner, but it's a powerful image nonetheless. And, not surprisingly, the denials also happen to be a lie:
White House press secretary Scott McClellan later acknowledged that the sign was produced by the White House.

Part of remembrance is using it to help guide you in the future, so it is fair to ask, what is our current mission? both in Iraq and generally?

Some have argued that our new mission should be energy independence. The Apollo Alliance has teamed unions up with activists to push for creation of a lot of new skilled jobs, ripe for unionization, by ramping up alternative energy. But what chance do a bunch of panty-waist liberals have of getting something like this going? Those sissies that care about things like jobs and planets--who cares what they think?

Well, it turns out the most macho organization on Earth, the US military, needs to care about it, too. You'd think the strategic costs alone would have made energy independence obvious to the military long ago, since getting fuel to troops in the field has become extremely problematic. And the troops in the field need nothing like they need fuel: an Abrams tank gets a whopping 0.6 miles/gallon!

But now the military officially knows the obvious, as the Boston Globe revealed today that the Department of Defense has received a report telling them about it:
A new study ordered by the Pentagon warns that the rising cost and dwindling supply of oil -- the lifeblood of fighter jets, warships, and tanks -- will make the US military's ability to respond to hot spots around the world "unsustainable in the long term."

The study, produced by a defense consulting firm, concludes that all four branches of the military must "fundamentally transform" their assumptions about energy, including taking immediate steps toward fielding weapons systems and aircraft that run on alternative and renewable fuels. It is "imperative" that the Department of Defense "apply new energy technologies that address alternative supply sources and efficient consumption across all aspects of military operations," according to the report, which was provided to the Globe.
...
The Department of Defense is the largest single energy consumer in the country. The Air Force spends about $5 billion a year on fuel, mostly to support flight operations. The Navy and Army are close behind.

Of all the cargo the military transports, more than half consists of fuel. About 80 percent of all material transported on the battlefield is fuel.
...
The costs of relying on oil to power the military are consuming an increasing share of the military's budget, the report asserts. Energy costs have doubled since the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, it says, and the cost of conducting operations could become so expensive in the future that the military will not be able to pay for some of its new weapon systems.
Creating three million new union jobs in alternative energy production, as the Apollo Alliance wants, seems to me like the perfect way to remember appropriate parties while moving forward with a new mission. In a few years, hopefully we can remember the days when labor was on the decline in America as income inequality was on the rise. And hopefully we can likewise look back on the days when we fought wars half-way around the world over oil.

Labels: , , ,

Monday, February 26, 2007

Greenwashing


Environmentalists have a shaky relationship with corporations. Corporations are the biggest, most powerful, most unified force fighting to destroy the environment. Business gets a lot cheaper when you can just dump your waste in the creek, as it were.

Corporations have a shaky relationship with environmentalists. Corporations like the environmentalist seal of approval because it gives them good PR. But environmentalists demand that corporations actually do something good for the environment before getting support.

This is where the concept of "greenwashing" comes in. To whitewash a problem means to do something very superficial that makes everything seem better without solving anything. To greenwash is to do something superficial to make yourself appear environmentally responsible without putting anything behind it.

A classic example of greenwashing is so-called "clean coal".

This ad from GE last year is disgusting on a number of levels, not least of which is that it combines a folk song about the horrendous exploitation of coal miners over the last couple centuries with Zoolander-style models strutting around. All for the sake of a "coal is great" message. But the real issue here is portraying coal as clean. Granted, there are ways to filter out some of the most disgusting particulate burn-off (aka soot) that coal plants generate, but they still generate huge amounts of CO2. It might be possible to have cleanER coal, there will never be any such thing as clean coal.

This morning, evil energy giant TXU, which had been aggressively trying to build more coal power plants without even pretending to make them clean, has been bought out. Not only that, but the new owners are pledging to stop building (so many) coal plants. Not only that, but they are also pledging to support government regulations capping CO2 emissions!

The head of one of the equity firms involved is also on the board of the World Wildlife Fund. So someone in the process has an environmental conscious, which pretty much explains why the deal worked out as it did.

Do we need to worry that this deal is just greenwashing? TXU was originally going to be building 11 coal plants, and now they're scaling it back to 3. That's cool and all, because it's a big reduction. But if it's a bad idea to build 11 new particulate-spewing, climate destroying power plants, why is it still a good idea to build 3?

In the end, I don't think this deal is greenwashing. It's not as great as it would be if environmentalists conceived and executed it from start to finish, but it's tremendous progress. The interests behind this have involved more people, and made more serious commitments, than they would have if they didn't mean it. And, as the Post article quotes an anonymous source saying, getting a big energy concern like TXU to do this may go a long way to changing a lot of minds among traditional opponents of the environment.

Update - 2/27:
The Christian Science Monitor has an article today pointing up the increased relevance of environmental costs for Wall Street. I take this as partial confirmation that the TXU deal is more than simple greenwashing.

Update 2 - 2/27:
Yes, I'm aware that the GE video is strikingly similar to this idiotic (hot?) techno video from several years ago:

Labels: , , , ,