Monday, March 05, 2007

Leadership Vacuum

In the previous post, my colleague Benediktion writes about the difference between moral high ground and action in the context of divesting from Darfur and stopping the Iraq occupation. Although I disagree with several of the things he says, I'm glad he brought it up. These are vitally important issues, and the context in which we deal with them lends itself well to Sartre's analysis of man: his identity is constructed by his actions, not his words.

Last November, Americans came out and took action en masse, giving form to their dissatisfaction by kicking the Republicans out of power in Congress. But outside of elections, the people in a representative democracy retain their ability to speak while delegating their ability to act. So, despite the fact that there are various issues on which the people demand action, the beltway politicos are content to make sure their demands stay mere words.

First case in point: Iraq. Three quarters of respondents to the most recent CBS News/New York Times poll thought things were going badly or very badly in Iraq. Iraq was clearly a major factor in the 2006 elections. Yet so far, the Democratic majority has responded by letting Bush's escalation go forward, not supporting measures with teeth to bring an end to the occupation, and letting Joe Lieberman give the weekly radio address. The Administration promised the escalation would be different because this time we were seriously going to hold the Iraqis to some benchmarks. Now that benchmarks have already been missed, no one is pressing the administration on it.

Second case in point: health care. A stunning poll was released last week that was basically ignored by most media. It turns out Americans support single payer health care. Big time. Health care is the most important issue for a majority (not just a plurality) of the respondents, 64% think the government should guarantee coverage, and 60% we would be willing to pay more in taxes so that everyone could have guaranteed coverage. A popular mandate for the best solution to the preeminent domestic policy problem of our day would seemingly translate to major action by the government, right? So why haven't the Democrats jumped at this opportunity to help people and make themselves look good?

As Michael Tomasky notes,
What we don't know about the Democrats at this point is whether the party has an interest in summoning Americans to think about the world from a broader perspective than how a given issue affects them directly.
Because that's what health care and Iraq are about. Sure some people are directly affected by the health care crisis or Iraq, but most people aren't. Or at least they don't feel like it. But people recognize that these are the important issues in America today. People want them solved. Visionaries are those who solve big issues, not those who solve easy ones.

Visionaries are what we need, and it is easier to be a visionary from the White House (or at least a presidential campaign) than it is from the halls of compromise (read: Congress). Fortunately, Democrats currently have a bumper crop of great presidential candidates, at least so goes the conventional wisdom. Edwards, Clinton, and Obama are considered to be form an unusually strong field for Democrats.

Unfortunately, all these great candidates are taking equally cowardly approaches to substance. Obama, especially, has "decided to run--à la Gary Hart in 1984--on the notion of new ideas without actually offering any." Establishment Democrats clearly need more encouragement to start acting on the values they sometimes seem to have. We spent a really long time (from 1994 to present) in this defensive crouch, so I guess it's too much to expect one little election to immediately break the bad habits. But it's frustrating - our people are finally in office, so why aren't they doing the things we want? For now, all we can do is keep the pressure up on our representatives. Hopefully sooner or later one of these great candidates will emerge to make Democrats do what they must know they need to do.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, February 07, 2007

Healthy, Wealthy, and Wise

Big news in health care today, as a new super coalition is going to try to tackle America's insurance mess. The new group, vapidly titled Better Health Care Together, brings together unlikely partners such as the Service Employees International Union (SEIU), Center for American Progress, Wal*Mart, and AT&T. The idea is to promote these four bland and content-free action items:

1) We believe each person in America must be guaranteed access to quality, affordable health insurance coverage;

2) We believe individuals have a responsibility to maintain and protect their health;

3) We believe that America must dramatically improve the value it receives for every health care dollar; and

4) We believe that businesses, governments, and individuals all should contribute to managing and financing a new American health care system.

The interesting part of this news is obviously not the action items but rather the coalition itself. Previous efforts at health care reform have been stymied by business interests, led especially by health insurance companies. Somehow the insurance industry got it in its head that eliminating private health insurance would be bad for their business model, and they will do everything they can to stop the most effective reform: eliminating private health insurance, just like every other advanced country:
Every other advanced nation in the world has a national health care system for all. Try asking a crowd of people if they know anyone in Europe who doesn't have health care coverage. Or in Taiwan, Singapore, Japan, South Korea, Malta, Costa Rica, Cuba or dozens of other countries in the world..

It's not an easy thing to do when you want to eliminate an entire sector of your economy for the health, as it were, of the rest of the economy. But it will be easier if big corporations that have previously sided with health insurers throw their weight behind fixing the problem. Not just because they are the largest consumers of health insurance and will be listened to, but also because you have to have corporate money talking if you want any Republicans to listen.

The good news is that for the last couple of years, big business has started to realize how much it's getting screwed by the current employer-provided system. Notably, GM announced that health care expenses were adding thousands of dollars per vehicle in extra costs to their bottom line. GM reasoned that this was forcing them to be less competitive on the global marketplace, since their competitors have operations in countries with sensible health care systems. Now, this is pretty much BS, since GM's lack of competitiveness is more easily traced to their willingness to let Honda and Toyota make much better cars with much better gas mileage. But overpaying for health care isn't doing big powerful corporations any favors, and the point is that they now realize it.

So perhaps we have reach an impasse. Big corporations want to stop paying for health insurance, and health insurance companies want people to keep buying it. It would take a real visionary, decider, uniter of a politician to craft the delicate solution that could fix this problem. Fortunately, George W. Bush is still in office, and the health care plan he announced at the State of the Union Address addresses every corporation's worry. It changes tax incentives to make it more economical for people to buy their own private insurance and less economical for them to get it through their employer. But by sticking with private insurance, the HMOs get to keep making a profit off denying people medical treatment This is not an adequate solution, and fortunately it doesn't look like the Democratic Congress is going to jump up and help Bush make it work.

That's the real beauty of this coalition. It isolates the health insurance companies from their erstwhile allies in big business, and it lends legitimacy to the only actual solution. By combining the forces of the Wise (people who want to see effective, efficient coverage for everyone) with the Wealthy (those who want to see costs become reasonable), we can only end up with the one rational solution for making everyone in America more Healthy: single payer care.

Labels: , , ,